Unsettled Geeks Buylist FAQ

Selling your cards to Unsettled Geeks is easy, transparent, and fair. This FAQ explains how our buylist works, what conditions we accept, and what to expect when selling cards to us.

What is the Unsettled Geeks Buylist?

Our buylist shows the cards and products we are currently buying from players. Prices are based on market demand and our inventory needs and are updated regularly.

How can I sell cards to you?

In-Store

Submit your buy list and wait for an approval email. Once approved, bring your cards to our store for review and payment.

For large collections, we strongly recommend contacting us first.

How long before my buy list is approved?

Most buy list are approved within 24 hours, but large buy list can take up to 48 hours.

What condition do my cards need to be in?

Buylist prices assume Near Mint (NM) condition unless otherwise stated.

We use the following condition standards:

Card Condition Guide

Near Mint (NM / NM Foil)

Cards in Near Mint condition show minimal wear from handling or play.

They may have:

• Slight edge wear

• One or two very minor scratches

They should still have:

• Clean surface

• Crisp corners

• No major defects

Near Mint includes cards with no imperfections and cards with only very small, barely noticeable flaws.

Important: Manufacturing defects (such as severe miscuts or shifting) may cause a card to be treated as Damaged.

Lightly Played (LP / LP Foil)

Cards in Lightly Played condition may show minor wear.

They may have:

• Small edge wear

• Light scuffs or scratches

Imperfections are visible but not severe and do not affect the structure of the card.

Moderately Played (MP / MP Foil)

Cards in Moderately Played condition show noticeable wear.

They may have:

• Clear edge or surface wear

• Scratching or scuffing

• Bends or light creases

Some defects (bends, peeling, minor liquid exposure) may be acceptable as long as the card is still structurally intact.

Heavily Played (HP / HP Foil)

Cards in Heavily Played condition show heavy wear.

They may have:

• Significant whitening

• Creases

• Many visible imperfections

Cards must still be authentic and structurally intact.

Damaged

Damaged cards have severe issues that affect the integrity of the card.

They may have:

• Tears or splits

• Major creases

• Foreign substances (food, liquid, etc.)

• Severe bending or warping

Cards with foreign substances are not accepted.

How do you determine condition?

Final condition is determined by Unsettled Geeks staff upon inspection using in-house standards.

Condition is assessed for:

• Surface quality

• Corners and edges

• Structural integrity

Our evaluations are final, but we’re always happy to explain our reasoning.

What happens if my cards are not Near Mint?

If a card is not NM:

• The offer will be adjusted based on its condition

• You can accept the adjusted price or request the card back

Are buylist prices guaranteed?

No. Buylist prices are not locked until we receive and verify your cards.

Prices may change due to:

• Market volatility

• Condition differences

• Inventory limits

How do I get paid?

We offer:

• Store Credit (best value)

• Cash (in-store only)

• Digital payment (Venmo, Cashapp or Paypal)

Is store credit better than cash?

Yes — store credit typically receives a higher payout than cash.

Do you buy bulk?

Yes, we buy bulk under specific conditions.

Bulk must be:

• Sorted by game

• Free of damaged or dirty cards

• Mostly Near Mint

We reserve the right to refuse unsorted or poor-quality bulk.

Do you buy sealed products?

No.

Do you buy collections?

Yes — we love buying collections.

For large collections:

• Please contact us first

• Buy list are highly recommended

• Processing may take several days

How long does processing take?

Typical timelines:

• In-store: Same day or within 24 hours

Large collections may take longer.

What if I disagree with your evaluation?

Our staff makes final determinations, but we will always:

• Explain condition issues

• Walk you through the pricing

We aim to be transparent and fair.

Can you refuse to buy cards?

Yes. We reserve the right to refuse any transaction, including for:

• Counterfeit cards

• Stolen property

• Heavily damaged or contaminated cards

• Excess inventory

Do you accept counterfeit cards?

No. Counterfeit cards are not accepted and will not be returned.

Do I need ID?

Yes — valid photo ID is required for cash transactions.

Final Terms

By submitting cards to Unsettled Geeks, you agree to all policies and terms listed on this page. All condition evaluations and pricing decisions are made at our discretion.

If you have any questions, please reach out to info@unsettledgeeks.com and we'd be happy to assist you.